What if I said South Sumatra’s peatland does not burn solely because of drought or El Niño?
It burns because peatlands are commonly described as idle land with no productive value, a viewpoint that has shaped conversion with little scrutiny.
And land that no one values is land that no one protects.
---
If you grew up in Palembang, you know that at a certain time of the year, you should be ready for the smoke haze! Then be prepared to not see the blue sky for several months.
I remember a story from my childhood that Mom kept repeating: Mom said my grandpa used to take me for an afternoon stroll around the city. When we got back home, little me made a report to Mom said, "Palembang banyak asap," which means there is a lot of smoke in Palembang. It was more than 30 years ago. Imagine, this annual disaster happened even long ago. Thirty years later, nothing has really changed.
Another one, ten years ago, as a master’s student, I flew home from Delft to collect field data. It was smoke season. In the Netherlands, I had gotten so used to clean air that I never thought about it. In Palembang, clean air was scarce. That was my first reverse culture shock!
This year, the haze came back even harder than before. I am far from Palembang now, and I feel two things at once: thankful that I can inhale fresh air, and guilty at the same time, because my family (cats included) and friends have been breathing hazardous air for months. By late July 2026, satellites had counted more fire hotspots in Indonesia than at the same point in any year since the big fire seasons of 2019 and 2023.
And every time, we hear the same explanation.
Drought. El Niño. Climate Change.
But if I were El Niño, I would be furious, because all the blame falls on me.
Well, it is not wrong, but it is too short, and it puts all the blame on one side. El Niño brings drought; drought lowers peat water levels, and dry peat burns more easily (Khakim et.al., 2022). But the fires are also part of a much longer story.
In Catastrophe and Regeneration in Indonesia’s Peatlands: Ecology, Economy and Society by Mizuno et al. (2016), it is shown that these peatlands have been vulnerable to fire for centuries: through the Sultanate era, Dutch colonial rule, independence, and the New Order, when peatlands were opened on a massive scale because they were seen as land with no potential. Later, the government created a special agency to address peatland damage: the Peatland Restoration Agency (BRG-Badan Restorasi Gambut, now BRGM (Badan Restorasi Gambut dan Mangrove).
Please note, our ancestors also used fire to clear peatland and open land for their own agricultural purposes, so prescribed burning is not a new thing, but those fires were small and limited, not massive like the clearing for oil palm and pulp plantations today.
Left undisturbed, peatland can take care of itself. Yet we seem not to learn. We keep repeating the wild assumptions that peatland has no value, and that it should be turned into something that makes money. Yay! *sarcastically
Little did we know, this careless belief is where the environmental damage begins.
---
Read any report about burned peat in Sumatra and the same words keep showing up.
Degraded. Idle. Under-valued. Wasted. Critical. Marginal.
In Indonesian, we say lahan kosong or lahan tidur: empty land, sleeping land. Those words sound like descriptions but they work like permission.
Once land is called empty, nobody has to ask what it's doing. It becomes a blank space on a map, waiting for something “useful” to happen: oil palm, acacia, rice fields, houses, you name it!
Here's the loop. Once you see it, you can't unsee it.
- Peat gets labeled low-value.
- Because it's “low-value,” it gets drained with canals for plantations or farming.
- The canals lower the water table.
- Peat that stayed soaked for thousands of years starts to dry out.
- Dry peat grows grass. Dry grass is perfect fuel for burning.
- A dry season comes, worse in an El Niño year. Fire started.
- After the fire, the land looks even worse. More “degraded.” More “empty".
- Empty and degraded means conversion to something more productive.
The fire doesn't end the damage. It becomes the proof used to justify the next round, which is land use conversion, into something only God knows.
A study in South Sumatra by Irfan et al., (2024) matched groundwater levels against 20 yrs of fire hotspots. Once the water table drops below about 45 centimeters under the surface, fire risk jumps significantly. In a strong El Niño event, the water table can fall 1 to 1.5 meters.
Now look at what happens when we dry out the peat. In 2015, there was a very dry year. Peat forests that people didn't alter barely burned. Only about 3 fires in an area of 100 sqkm. But peatlands that people had dried out? About 85 to 90 fires in the same size of area (Miettinen et al., 2017).
During that severe dry season, South Sumatra was among the worst affected. It had only a small part of the peatland, but a large share of the fires, because the peatland had been so altered.
Once it burns, it becomes easier to burn again. In Ogan Komering Ilir, peatland that has burned many times is now covered by ferns and purun grass, with almost no trees left (Siahaan, 2025). In the dry season, these plants become fuel, and they help the next fire start and spread (Yulianti et al., 2020).
So, here is the verdict: Manmade canals dry the peat - Grass moves in - Grass is fuel; it burns easily - The next fire comes easier.
We can always blame El Niño for bringing the dry weather. But we forgot that the land was set up to burn!
---
It's easy to blame the person who started the fire, but what if this started decades ago?
From the 1970s, the swamp forests of southern Sumatra were opened up by logging concessions and transmigration programs. Canals were dug. Plantation licenses were handed out Chokkalingam et. al., (2009). They followed three swamp areas in southern Sumatra (Sugihan, Mesuji and Pampangan). All three went from rich, mixed forest to degraded sedge after logging, transmigration, and plantations moved in.
When the man-made canals existed, the same small fire that once stopped at the water’s edge now had dry peat to burn. The farmers kept doing what they had always done. But the land had changed, and now it burned out of control. See the pattern here?
Then, if we zoom out to Southeast Asia, you'll see the picture gets worse. Peat swamp forest covered 84% of the region's peatland in 1985. By 2010, it was 36% (Dohong et al., 2017). The main drivers are pretty similar: logging, drainage, and fire. And fire does something extra cruel here. It burns the seed bank and the parent trees. The forest loses the important tools it needs to come back.
---
Then, who breathes the smoke? People who knew nothing about this, and who never deserved to breathe lethal air.
And the people closest to the fire pay even more. A survey of 300 farm households in Ogan Komering Ilir (Yazid et al., 2024) found that fire hurts them in many ways at once: socially, economically, ecologically, and in their daily livelihoods. Families with small children and elderly members were among the most exposed. The people who gained the least from draining the peat are the ones who breathe the most smoke.
The people who earned the least from draining the peat breathe the most smoke. We can talk about climate justice if we want to go further into this topic.
![]() |
| Figure 1. Satellite image of South Sumatra (Source: NASA, 2026) |
From August to October 2025, South Sumatra had only scattered fires, and the air above it stayed mostly clear. In the same months of 2026, satellites detected about 21 times more fires. The longest-burning fires, sometimes ten days or more in the same place, clustered in the eastern lowlands where peat lies. That is how peat burns slowly, underground, for days.
So, what fire leaves behind?
After a few rounds of fire, little remains to defend. On repeatedly burned peat in Ogan Komering Ilir, Siahaan (2025) found only about 8.46 tons of carbon per hectare in the plants that remained. Plant diversity was low. Mainly, only grass covered the ground. Not a single full-grown tree was left. What a pathetic condition to describe! What a perfect condition for opening the land for plantation!
The carbon that used to be there didn’t vanish. It went into the air. Every kilogram of peat that burns releases about 1,544 grams of CO₂ (Yokelson et al., 2022). In September and October 2015, the fires released about 11.3 million tons of carbon every day (Huijnen et al., 2016).
Every day! Now imagine 2026! with conditions even worse!
Just picture it in your head, and suddenly you can almost feel the smoke in your lungs!
---
At what cost?
- The 2015 fires alone released about 1.2 billion tons of CO₂-equivalent. (source)
- The 2019 Indonesia’s fires released around 720 million tons of CO₂, almost double the emissions from that year’s Amazon fires, largely because so much peat burned (World Bank, 2019)
- In 2015, nearly half a million people in Sumatra and Kalimantan suffered acute respiratory infections (source).
- The haze caused about 100,300 early deaths across Indonesia, Malaysia, and Singapore, with much of the increase coming from fires in South Sumatra (source).
- In 2019, over 900,000 people reported respiratory illnesses, and the World Bank estimated the economic loss at $5.2 billion, about 0.5% of Indonesia’s GDP (source).
- By early October 2026, Indonesia’s fires had released 140.5 million tonnes of carbon, about 13% of all fire emissions in the world. (source)
- The government’s official data counted about 202,000 hectares burned by July, while independent satellite estimates put it at more than 1.9 million hectares by September (source).
- In South Sumatra alone, more than 430,000 cases of acute respiratory infection were recorded by mid-October 2026, most of them children. (source)
- Independent economists estimate the losses so far at up to Rp167 trillion, about 0.65% of Indonesia’s GDP. (source)
- Reports 113,883 ISPA (Respiratory cases) in Palembang, January–August 2026, the highest in South Sumatra. (source)
- And so on....
We lose lives and health.
We lose money.
We lose time.
We lose an ecosystem.
We lose our integrity.
And we lose trust.
Every year, the smoke crosses borders (since smoke doesn't have an ID, just like the wind), and neighboring countries ask why it keeps happening. Every year, the people breathing it ask the same question.
All of this, for land we once called empty.
---
It's not empty. It's just not counted.
We measure it. We just never price it.
This is what makes me angry and sad, and my eco anxiety level goes up.
Even burned, even “degraded,” this land is still working. It still holds water. It still holds carbon. It still feeds fish, grass, fowl, and families live there. We call it dead because we haven't looked and understood it yet.
Sumatra’s peat may be one of Indonesia's most studied landscapes. The data is there. The maps are there. The models are there. Then the problem is where all that knowledge goes to submerge? into oblivion!
Indonesia does not lack peatland regulations. Rules on peat ecosystem protection, groundwater levels, and moratoriums on new permits have been in place for years, many introduced after the 2015 fire crisis (PP 71/2014, amended by PP 57/2016, Inpres 5/2019, making the moratorium on clearing primary forest and peatland permanent). Yet fires keep returning to the same landscapes.
I believe part of this lies in the gap between policy and practice. Peatland regulations are largely applied permit by permit and parcel by parcel, while peat functions as a connected hydrological landscape. See the discrepancy?
We keep studying, measuring, writing reports, building models, and publishing papers. But what is the point if no one cares?
Knowledge that never reaches policy is just bullshit. Research that never becomes enforcement is just a diary of a teenage girl which gonna be kept under their bed or in the attic once she becomes an adult.
Year after year, the evidence piles up, and the disaster accumulates. In this ceremonial country, the government is just busy being reactive rather than preventive. The question is now shifting to: until when?
Indonesia’s peatlands and mangroves hold billions of tons of carbon. That number shows up in national climate reports, in speeches, in international IPCC meetings. But it disappears the moment someone with something to gain decides to convert the land.
The value was never missing. It was just never invited to the table.
Figure 3 shows the land use changes pattern in South Sumatra (2015-2023). The satellite maps tell the same story. In 2015, only about one-tenth of South Sumatra’s peat was still covered by undisturbed swamp forest. By 2023, that had dropped to less than 8%. In just eight years, more than a quarter of the remaining undisturbed peat forest was degraded or cleared.
---
Can it come back? Yes but slowly.
There is good news amidst all of these bad reports.
Yes, peat can heal. But it takes hundreds of years!
The nature we lose today will not fully return for our grandchildren.
It is the full contradiction of sustainability that we learned at school, right?
That is why I write this. I don’t want my great-grandchildren to know peatland only as smoke in the sky. or only as a picture in a history book. Do you want?
---
Why do we, as landscape architects, need to care?
As someone who cares deeply about landscapes and keeps learning to contemplate this ecosystem, I want to be clear: these fires are not unstoppable. The smoke of August to October 2026 did not have to happen. We have seen this disaster again and again. All we need is to learn from it, think critically, and finally accept that peatland has value of its own.
But every year, the same story plays out. The response always comes after the smoke, never before the fire. Helicopters, water-bombing planes, cloud seeding, we are very good at fighting fires we already allowed to start. We are much worse at keeping peat wet in the months when no one is watching.
We are always one step behind the careless hands that want to destroy the beauty of this country. I am not here to dictate what should be done. That is not my capacity, and I do not have that kind of power. If you are reading this, I only want to invite you to think a little deeper, a little more critically. It was never empty land. Because...
You cannot govern a landscape you refuse to understand.





Comments
Post a Comment